Lyrics

[Verse 1]
You walked into my life when I was craving something reckless,
Tired of being responsible, tired of being self-protective.
You looked at me across the room like you already knew
Exactly what a lonely woman secretly wanted you to do.
I knew you had somebody, you knew I wasn’t free,
But temptation made a private place for you and me.
One drink became your hotel, one kiss became the night,
And everything that felt so good became so hard to make right.

[Chorus]
You caught me at the wrong time,
When my body wanted danger and my heart ignored the signs.
You made forbidden feel tender, made a secret feel divine,
But the morning brought the guilt back when your skin released mine.
I can’t call it destiny just because you crossed that line.
You caught me at the wrong time.

[Verse 2]
Now you keep saying leave him, but you still sleep next to her,
Telling me our situation is too special to disturb.
You want me to risk everything while you protect your home,
Want my nights, my deepest feelings, but won’t give me all your own.
I started as your fantasy, then feelings entered in,
And now I’m jealous of a woman who was there before this sin.
I hate the way I need you, hate the way you make me wait,
Hate how something so seductive grew into emotional weight.

[Bridge]
We were never innocent, no matter how it felt.
We knew the hearts attached to every secret we withheld.
The lesson isn’t that desire was a feeling we should hide.
It’s that wanting one another didn’t make deception right.

[Final Chorus]
You caught me at the wrong time,
When I confused attention with a love that could be mine.
You made forbidden feel tender, but a secret has a price.
And being wanted after midnight isn’t worth another lie.
I’m ending what we started before it steals the rest of mine.
You caught me at the wrong time.